Sri Lanka's cricket captain; why there were better choices than Dilshan

By Michael Roberts | April 19, 2011

The following was authored on Sunday night, April 17, in response to a request from Saroj Pathirana of  BBC Sandēsaya Service. It was one step behind events, because Tillkaratne Dilshan has been appointed captain for all three formats. So, the title has been altered and it is presented here because it provides fodder for reflection and comment.

TM Dilshan
The energetic Tillakaratne Dilshan appointed as captain of Sri Lanka. AFP PHOTO/Indranil MUKHERJEE.

As Sri Lanka ruminates over the choice of its cricket captain for the heavy programme of matches scheduled over the next year or so, Tillakaratne Dilshan’s name features prominently. Dilshan (aged 34+) is a mercurial cricketer, lightening quick over the ground, a wonderful fielder in any position, a Genghis Khan of a batsman and a useful change bowler. He is a bloke I, if ever a captain at this level, would yearn to have in my side.

He has captained Sri Lanka in a series in Zimbabwe before, but it was precisely during that tour that questions arose about his off-field ethics. That is hardly a heritage to bring to such a high-profile position as captain of Si Lanka.

There is yet another reason, in my book, for keeping him in the side as vital senior player and not as captain. He will push the boundaries of cricketing sportsmanship to its limits and even beyond the limits. He is the nearest thing to the hard-nosed Australian in our cricketing scene.

I do not want Sri Lanka to have an Australian captain. We must retain the toughness girded by grace and moderation and fairness, which Jayawardene and Sangakkara brought to their tenures.

Dilshan is also impulsive. Such imperatives are disastrous when UDRS issues (referrals) arise. We need cool captains who does not indulge in wishful thinking in the manner of a Sehwag or Dilshan.

So, where does that leave us?

One line of possibility is a split captaincy with Thilan Samaraweera (aged 34+) as captain for Tests backed up by Angelo Mathews as vice-captain, and a Upul Tharanga-Mathews combination for ODIs.

Angelo MathewsAnother path would be, to have Samaraweera as captain for Tests and as ODI captain for an year, or so, on the explicit understanding that Mathews (23+) or Tharanga (26) would be given that ODI role in, say, 18 months time.

Samaraweera proved an intelligent and fighting A Team captain in the early 2000s, just when he was moving from the role of off-spin bowler to that of gritty batsman. He has since improved his attacking skills as a batsman in recent years, under the tutelage of Chandika Hathurasinghe. He is not quick across the ground, but is a handy slip-fielder. By my reckoning, he has 2-5 years of cricket still left in him in the longer version of the game.

Mathews has experience as captain from the U14 stage at school and also as U19 captain in the international arena. He is said to be a mature young man. There is, therefore, a good argument for him to be adorned with the captaincy in both forms of the game from the year dot, that is, NOW, in 2011.

If this idea gains ground, then great care must be taken to provide him with a vice-captain with whom he can work, and one who has a good head on his shoulders. This could be even be Samaraweera or Tharanga.

But, finally, the best course may be to request Mahela Jayawardene to take on the role of captain as caretaker for 12-18 months, with Angelo Mathews as his vice-captain and understudy.

It will be evident that I am thinking on the run and juggling balls in the air. All these suggestions, moreover, are from a position outside the team, without any information on inner-team dynamics and personal relations within the team. Such an outsider-perspective can be seriously flawed. The Selection Committee must surely consult Kumar Sangakkara and Manager Anura Tennekoon — quietly and confidentially — before moving to such a momentous decision.

However, on a related issue I speak with greater confidence. Sri Lanka Cricket (SLC) must ensure a system is in place to relieve the captain of duties pertaining to player contracts and the organisation of practice sessions. Sangakkara was mentally drained from the pressure associated with such tasks. The office-bearers of the Players Association must be given due weight and permitted to bear the burden of contract negotiations.

The coach they select must be an organisation man in the mould of Tom Moody and Shane Duff; individuals, who attend to the minutiae of training in methodical fashion, unlike the more recent incumbent. They must also insist on a coach who is prepared to bring his family to Sri Lanka and is able to work with the younger players in the periods between series - that is as important as coaching tasks in the heat of battle.

Rhodes Scholar for Ceylon in 1962, Michael Roberts is a historian by training and has taught at the Department of History at Peradeniya University (1961-76) and the Department of Anthropology at Adelaide University (1977-2003).

© Michael Roberts/Island Cricket


Anonymous's picture

[This comment has been removed, as it is not consistent with our comment submission guidelines.]

cliff's picture

before taking up this important role Dilshan must be first sent to a Good English course since he will be having the task to talk with all the international media and commentators on and off the field.

Common person's picture

I think dilshan is a good choice because we need aggressiveness to our team.why every educated people are criticising him because he doesnt have a good english knowledge.but at the end of the day he would bring us glory

L. Perera's picture

Yes, Dilshan has to do something about his "impulsivness", when in the role of Captain. This is something that could be easily sorted out. But
as for his 'aggressivness' , I think Sri Lanka, definitly needs someone like Dilshan to lead the side. Watch out Australia ! you are about to meet your match.

Anonymous's picture

dilshan z the best choice

Anonymous's picture

So if Dilshans team does not get into the next world cup finals will he step down ??? If Sangas team got knocked out in the quarter finals will all this rubbish take place ? Our guys did so well to get into finals and without praising them, we hear people talking nonsense. Lets wait and see how Dilshan is going to manage the team. Its about time he pearce his other ear and nose as well!!!

Anonymous's picture

Dilshan has that magic touch with whatever he does,bat,ball,fielding and hopefully now with the captaincy.Tharanga isn't active enough for captaincy and Mathews is still too young for it.So Dilshan is the best choice.

Stormy's picture
Member since:
15 January 2011
Last activity:
4 days 48 min

Six of one half dozen of another the choice of the new SL captain. There really isnt an obvious choice. Appointing Thilan would require another captain for one dayers - surely we need to get past Thilan being the middle order fix in one dayers. Thilan would be a more conservative appointment on the traditional lines while Dilshan is more an unconventional appointment which is more in line with the way SL plays its cricket. It could go belly up quickly but there are no guarantees in the position SL is in right now. I would back the Dilshan appointment and hope for the best.

Chalani's picture

I dnt lyk Dilshan.yuk. Sangakkara is da best.I lyk him very much

Post new comment

All anonymous comments are moderated.
  • Avoid abusive remarks and personal attacks.
  • Avoid posting unrelated links.
  • Avoid vulgar or obscene language.
Already a member? Log-in now. Not a member? Sign up for a new account.
Enter each letter you see in the box below. It helps us prevent automated submissions from spammers.