Sachin Tendulkar's accomplishments are incredible — Arnold

Russel Arnold responds to questions from fans in his weekly column
April 29, 2013

PhotoWho out of these three players do you consider to be the best batsman of our generation: Sachin Tendulkar, Ricky Ponting or Brian Lara?Darren Singh

Comparing players is always tricky. What criteria do we judge them on? For Sachin to be playing for as long as he has, and to be performing at a very high standard as consistently as he has, is incredible - you can't look past that. But, if I was to pick one, Brian Lara is a batsman I enjoy watching.

Do you think Muttiah Muralitharan became predictable and less threatening after he developed the doosra?Manju De Zoysa

The only difference I recall is that Murali spun the off-spinner a lot less after developing the doosra and that was due to a change in his body position during delivery, but right throughout his career, with the new variations he brought in, he continued to be threatening.

Although Angelo Mathews was tipped to be the next captain for some time, do you think Sri Lanka should have ideally used a more matured player for captaincy until Mathews developed his game more? Some say that Mathews still had a long way to go before he could captain, what is your view? Do you feel the selectors could have used a more matured individual, ideally in his late 20s or early 30s, to captain the side instead of Mathews?Viran Fernando

Ideally, yes. That would have been the best way to go about it. The selectors did tread down that path, which is why they handed captaincy to Dilshan and Mahela after Sangakkara stepped down. But after Mahela, there just was no one around who could take over, so this is probably the best way forward.

Why do you think Sri Lanka always fails in World Cup finals? Can they get out of this trend? What do you think Sri Lanka's chances are in the next World Cup?D. Saman

Of course, they can most certainly beat that trend. The games were all lost under different circumstances, so it's more a case of being an unfortunate coincidence. Losses in past World Cup finals should be quickly forgotten and it must not be allowed to dominate the players' thinking. The next World Cup will be tougher than the last few, as it will be played in the southern hemisphere, where conditions are alien to players from the sub-continent. However, the guys have shown they can perform well in those conditions on recent tours there. Sri Lanka may not be favourites, but they are certainly dark horses.

I've played cricket for my alma mater, St.Aloysius' College, Galle, at all age limits and now I'm playing for my university, University of Ruhuna, and captaining the side. I also play in the premier league (division two) for Matara Sports Club. My question is on Thisara Perera, who is extremely talented and a great asset. In my opinion, he is the best all-rounder in the country so far and his batting has vastly improved, however, seeing him playing in the last couple of series, especially in the SLPL, Big Bash and IPL, I find him struggling, although he is scoring quick thirties and forties. If his main scoring shot is blocked, there is no other convincing shot to be played - he is limited. When he does connect, he hits them hard as Chris Gayle or Kieron Pollard. Thisara Perera and his batting coaches should focus their attention towards his batting more and he should find a way of scoring all around the wicket. He would then become a handful and a captain's nightmare. Do you agree, what's your view?Vidula Wijesirinarayana

I agree with you to some extent. Focusing on his batting should be done without compromising his strengths though. The work is being done on his batting. He should be cautious that he does not lose his natural aggression and he should continue trusting his strengths, while finding ways to combat his weaknesses.

Do you think the Galle surface has become too batsman-friendly, and is this a bad thing?Ranmal Prasad Perera

I believe that Galle surface we saw, in the last Test played there, was a one-off. We may not see another batsmen-friendly surface like that again at Galle.

Ask Russel Arnold a question »

© Island Cricket


UppercuT's picture
Member since:
19 October 2011
Last activity:
2 years 8 weeks

!Vidula Wijesirinarayana! :D)))))

Didula Abesirinarayana's picture

I've played EA Cricket '07 for 5 years and captained Sri Lanka to 6 world cup wins.Also I play carrom at the university.Guys,am I qualified enough to ask Russel a question?

Sakthivel's picture
Member since:
28 March 2012
Last activity:
45 weeks 1 hour

Didula Abesirinarayana : Happy to hear that you took SL for 6 WC wins !!!!

Anonymous's picture

Selfishkar plays for stats, he's not even the best batsman produced by India. Gavaskar and Dravid were better. VVS the ultimate match winner for India.

Anonymous's picture

I predict Kallis, the best cricketer since Sobers, will score more hundreds and accumulate more runs than Selfishkar.

Anonymous's picture

The best batsmen of our generation (1) Lara (2) Kallis (3) Ponting (4) Dravid (5) Selfishkar

kk_mix412's picture
Member since:
4 August 2012
Last activity:
5 years 12 weeks

Opinion of one anonymous s**t wont matters to anyone.

Stat-chin Selfish-kar's picture

The other day in an IPL match, Statchin showed his bat to the umpire after clearly ball hitting his pad and running away for 4! Any other batsman wudnt have mind whether it's runs or legbyes since the runs counted for the team, but this Selfishkar had to show the bat to the umpire to get those runs to his name and this is not even international match, this is IPL!!!! shows how much he cares abt himself more than the team!!

Phillips's picture

Before the doosra murali's off spinner spun at right angles but after doosra he was bowling more closer to the stumps and lost that ripping off break.

Sakthivel's picture
Member since:
28 March 2012
Last activity:
45 weeks 1 hour

@ KK :Bro, There are many of them in SL lol., Who cant and wont accept the fact that Sachin is one of the greats.

Honsetly there is no suprise that Russel not picking Sachin, that doesnt even matters !!!

Post new comment

All anonymous comments are moderated.
  • Avoid abusive remarks and personal attacks.
  • Avoid posting unrelated links.
  • Avoid vulgar or obscene language.
Already a member? Log-in now. Not a member? Sign up for a new account.
This step helps us prevent automated submissions from spammers.
3 + 4 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.